Friday, September 21, 2012

Modern Racism and College Speech Codes

Some background links:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WMBsO_95JJdVlMahc8ddLurufvYjHokQ8wrVnGAM8xA/edit?hl=en_US

https://docs.google.com/present/view?id=0AVf_DLqQA9ovZGZ2bTR3ZmdfMGZ6M25iNWc2&hl=en_US

This kind of behavior is despicable and idiotic.  I am almost at a loss for words.  I can't actually understand the purpose of these kinds of events.  Why do the participants say they are fun?  It bothers me to think that they were probably raised in an area that didn't discourage this kind of behavior.  Colleges have speech codes that probably prevent this kind of behavior, but a website, http://thefire.org/ has some cool stuff about what rules actually go against 1st Amendment rights.

Case Western Reserve University (a private institution in Cleveland, http://www.case.edu/) received a 'red light' rating from FIRE.  Reading through FIRE's explanation of the ratings for different rules, I had mixed feelings.  FIRE is concerned only with legality based on the 1st Amendment and is therefore very strict about free speech restrictions so many rules that I thought were reasonable were given a 'red' or 'yellow' light rating because they didn't allow for all the freedom of speech indicated by the 1st Amendment and various Supreme Court cases.  Having gone through the ratings I would say that CWRU isn't especially inhibiting.  The rules seemed reasonable (although they could potentially be overbearing if enforced to the letter) and I thought that the rules were much like rules at a public high school.

Going back to the first two links, I think that CWRU would have reacted similarly to Auburn in that they would have done some investigating and punished the involved students/Greek societies.  I would personally agree with this because I find the behavior of those students to be very offensive even though FIRE would probably have something to say about the constitutionality of the students' actions.

I think that FIRE is a could resource for getting an informed opinion, but because it has such a strong desire to follow the 1st Amendment to the letter (which isn't necessarily a bad thing) it rates relatively reasonable speech codes as infringing on students' rights (which I suppose technically they are although most students probably wouldn't mind).

I think that the 1st Amendment does a lot of good.  It is an integral part of America and what it means to be American, but I think that it also allows for potentially too much freedom.  How each person decides to interpret the 1st Amendment is their own choice, but I think that schools have a decent justification for their speech regulations.

No comments:

Post a Comment